jeremy 70 Posted October 9, 2007 Now I know that this seems to be a regular topic, however I wondered if people found that one arm/bush is more prone to failure. Until recently I had never given this much thought until I had to replace my offside wishbone, for the third time in less than eighteen months. The later two where brand new patern parts supplied by the garage that do my MOTs and covered less than 5K each . I truely believe that the ones supplied from the garage where very poorly made, as it was the same bush both times ie the one connected to the front of the subframe. The other contributing factor towards these failures I can only assume is down to my driving habbits on two particular roundabouts where LOOS makes the journey wothwile to say the least. I was just interested to know if others would agree or disagree with me here or not. Thanks Jeremy Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Alastairh 47 Posted October 9, 2007 (edited) In my experience with pattern wishbones i personally have used: They are ok for 5-8k then the bushes need changing, which is a bit of a pig, and you need to be suttle with a chisel and a lump hammer, but i wouldn't shell out for another pattern unit and it'll just go pop again! go to Peugeot and buy some genuine bushes (under £40 a pair) and they should last another 100k Thats what i have had to do on my cars plus a few friends Saying that, i know some people have had pattern wishbones that throw the ball joints, but seems odd ball... Al Edited October 9, 2007 by Alastairh Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Rippthrough 98 Posted October 9, 2007 My ECP ones on the 306 lasted about 8k before they were shot - al though it was hard use - polybushed them instead! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Pugnut 9 1 Cars Posted October 9, 2007 oe part no 3599.07 is both bushes and bolts to do one complete wishbone and is 17.74 including the vat. i normally blowtorch the old bushes out and knock the remaining sleeve out with a chisel. they go in nicely with a 6" vice. oe ones usually last much longer but the biggest contributing factor to thier early failure is tightening the bush bolt when the arm is not it the position it will normally sit with the wheels on the ground. as with all suspension components , the lower the car is the less time they will last . Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jeremy 70 Posted October 10, 2007 Thanks for all the responses however what I was trying to find out is there one particular side or particular bush or swivel joint that seems to fail quicker than the others. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Pugnut 9 1 Cars Posted October 10, 2007 oe part no 3599.07 is both bushes and bolts to do one complete wishbone and is 17.74 including the vat. i normally blowtorch the old bushes out and knock the remaining sleeve out with a chisel. they go in nicely with a 6" vice. oe ones usually last much longer but the biggest contributing factor to thier early failure is tightening the bush bolt when the arm is not it the position it will normally sit with the wheels on the ground. as with all suspension components , the lower the car is the less time they will last . just picked up the bush kit and found for the 17 odd quid it's a bush kit to do both sides (4 bushes, 4 bolts, 4 nuts and washers). pleasantly surprises. very good value for an oe kit. as for a particular weak area , i wouldnt say i've ever noticed one component bieng a problem compared with others but if you have an ovalled bottom hole on a hub or a worn shock absorber it will lead early failure of certain bushes, ball joints in that area Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
